Is It Organic? © 2008

Think organic food is tested? Think again...

Is it Organic?
Osoyoos, BC
Canada

ph: 250-495-2902
alt: 250-809-2914

In-depth media coverage

Support honest organic farmers!
Tired of all the "Good News" stories about the growth of organic farming? The truth is honest organic farmers are watching prices fall. Many are dropping their certifications, and many more good farmers will not bother to convert to organics even though they support the principles of organic farming.
Click here for a recent story on the decline of organics.

Respected Western Canadian Ag journalist Kevin Hursh, hits the nail square on the head.

Mischa Popoff, an organic crop inspector based in Osoyoos, B.C., is advancing a proposal for fixing organic certification and his views have generated some national media attention.

Popoff says more is needed than just the current written records with auditors who simply look at the paper trail. He proposes that organic crops be randomly tested in the field to ensure that no herbicides have been applied.

Organic producers face mountains of paperwork, but the system is largely ineffective in controlling fraud and negligence. Popoff claims the vast majority of independent organic farmers follow the rules and he says there's a great deal of support for the concept of random crop testing so that the industry has a greater scientific basis.

In many cases, scientific analysis can't tell the difference between organic and conventional products. Wheat or flax sprayed early in the growing season for weed control will show no evidence of that herbicide by harvest time.

However, plant samples can be tested in the middle of the growing season to help ensure organic practices are actually being followed. Without at least random testing, Popoff and others believe organic farming will lose credibility with consumers.

(Copyright 2008, The StarPhoenix)

For Kevin's full article, "Agriculture faces increasing consumer scrutiny", in the Saskatoon StarPhoenix, click here.


Bill Alpert, Senior Editor at Barron’s Weekly, also had the guts to hit the nail square on the head.

Many consumers think organic food has been tested for pesticides. But organic certifiers spend most of their time shuffling papers and auditing the files of farmers for records indicating that forbidden chemicals weren't used. Inspectors are typically free-lancers who receive a couple of hundred bucks for visiting a farm.

Mischa Popoff of British Columbia, Canada, was one of those inspectors. He visited hundreds of farms on behalf of organic certifiers and believes most of the farmers were credibly organic. But Popoff was frustrated when he'd see farms whose "organic" fields were as green and pest free as their conventional fields. One farmer's garage hid gallons of the herbicide Roundup. When Popoff made a fuss about these suspicious findings, he ... was blacklisted by some certification outfits.

Conscientious farmers go to a lot of trouble to be organic, so they worry about competing with cheaters who just want the price premiums that an organic label can command. Popoff argues that routine pesticide tests could catch cheaters, the way that drug tests snare doped athletes. But in the 1990s when the organic industry was helping to draft the federal law on organic labelling, the industry considered and rejected a requirement that organic food be residue-tested.

(Copyright 2007 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.)

For Bill's full article, "Do-Gooders Who Could Do Better" in Barron's click here.

Once again, please... 
Support organic farmers!

© 2008 Polyphase Communication Inc.

Web Hosting by Yahoo!

 

Is it Organic?
Osoyoos, BC
Canada

ph: 250-495-2902
alt: 250-809-2914